CLIENT: BUTTERNUT BOX

Increasing retention by supporting puppy parents

Butternut Box is offered as a subscription, discounted for the first two boxes. Data showed a significant drop off after the discounted period. Customers who had puppies churned at a higher rate than those with adult dogs after Box 2. My challenge was to increase retention with puppy owners.

Butternut Box is offered as a subscription, discounted for the first two boxes. Data showed a significant drop off after the discounted period. Customers who had puppies churned at a higher rate than those with adult dogs after Box 2. My challenge was to increase retention with puppy owners.

THE CHALLENGE

Increase retention

Increase lifetime loyalty

Build trust

Insights from data and focus groups

Puppy customers are likely to be more worried about getting things ‘right’, especially if it’s their first time owning a puppy

Puppy owners are generally more engaged with the digital proposition, more likely to refer and more likely to buy additional products

Puppy parents looked for high levels of breed specific support

In the first 3 months customers wanted advice about how to feed, socialisation and toilet training

From 3-6 months customers wanted advice about behaviour, enrichment and training

Puppies are likely to be fussy and/or go off food at different times of this high growth period

Hypothesis

Tailoring the Butternut experience for puppy customers is likely to increase retention as customers feel supported and see Butternut Box to be a trusted source of support throughout their dog’s life.

Early ideation

Picture uploads that customers can update as their pup grows - to drive ongoing engagement

Contextual help and advice according to the pups age

Video content from subject matter experts to engage and to establish the brand as a trusted advisor

Feeding tips to help customers feel confident about how much and often to feed - to build trust and encourage revisits

Feeding tips to help customers feel confident about how much and often to feed - to build trust and encourage revisits

Reiteration based on user testing

In user tests participants appreciated the age-specific tips, feeding guidance, and training videos

Participants particularly valued the relevant expert advice and tips

80% participants found the 'how to feed' and 'common puppy issues,' sections engaging and useful

Outcomes

Outcomes

Delivered a transformed, personalised puppy-parent experience

Tested strongly, with clear user enthusiasm for tailored guidance

Drove revisits and referrals via the new puppy-profile upload

Launched cleanly, strengthening early-life engagement and forecast to improve retention once data lands

THE CHALLENGE

Increase retention

Drive lifetime loyalty

Build trust

Eleanor Broderick